Clarification on Utah law concerning driving by minors

Over the past couple of weeks, I've heard lots of different things concerning Utah's law on driving by minors on which I'd previously considered myself somewhat of expert. People have told me of "new laws" only recently implemented amending what I had previously believed concerning the contents of Title 41, Chapter 8 of the Utah Code. So today, I went in and took a look at the code and decided to write a clarifying blog post. What follows is the exact wording used as well as a quick interpretation of the Chapter's three sections.

41-8-1: Operation of vehicle by persons under 16 prohibited -- Exceptions for off-highway vehicles and off-highway implements of husbandry.

(1) A person under 16 years of age, whether resident or nonresident of this state, may not operate a motor vehicle upon any highway of this state.
(2) This section does not apply to a person operating:
(a) a motor vehicle under a permit issued under Section 53-3-210.5;
(b) an off-highway vehicle registered under Section 41-22-3 either:
(i) on a highway designated as open for off-highway vehicle use; or
(ii) in the manner prescribed by Subsections 41-22-10.3(1) through (3); or
(c) an off-highway implement of husbandry in the manner prescribed by Subsections 41-22-5.5(3) through (5).

In other words: No one under the age of 16, irregardless of state residency, can drive on a State highway unless he/she has a Learner's Permit and is using it as outlined in 53-3-210.5, is driving an OHV in a legal way under 41-22-3 or 41-22-10.3 (1) through (3) or is driving an OHV used for husbandry under 41-22-5.5 (3) through (5). Basically, you can't drive here unless you're 16 or have a Permit.


41-8-2: Operation of vehicle by persons under 17 during night hours prohibited -- Exceptions.

(1) In addition to the provisions of Title 53, Chapter 3, Uniform Driver License Act, a person younger than 17 years of age, whether resident or nonresident of this state, may not operate a motor vehicle upon any highway of this state between the hours of 12:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m.
(2) It is an affirmative defense to a charge under Subsection (1) that the person is operating a motor vehicle:
(a) accompanied by a licensed driver at least 21 years of age who is occupying a seat next to the driver;
(b) for the driver's employment, including the trip to and from the driver's residence and the driver's employment;
(c) directly to the driver's residence from a school-sponsored activity if:
(i) transportation to the activity is provided by a school or school district; and
(ii) the transportation under Subsection (2)(c)(i) commences from and returns to the school property where the driver is enrolled;
(d) on assignment of a farmer or rancher and the driver is engaged in an agricultural operation; or
(e) in an emergency.
(3)
(a) In addition to any penalties imposed under Title 53, Chapter 3, Uniform Driver License Act, a violation of this section is a class C misdemeanor.
(b) A peace officer may not seize or impound a vehicle if:
(i) the operator of the vehicle is cited for a violation of this section; and
(ii) the seizure or impoundment is not otherwise authorized under Section 41-1a-1101, 41-6a-1405, 41-6a-1608, or 73-18-20.1 or required under Section 41-6a-527.

In other words: If you're not 17, you can't drive on a State highway between the hours of 12:00 A.M. and 5:00 A.M. unless you have a 21-year-old licensed driver in the passenger's seat, you're going to or from work, you're driving for your work, you're coming from a school-sponsored activity in which the school provided transportation and that transportation commenced from and terminated at the school, you're driving helping a farmer engage in agricultural operations, or you're in an emergency. In addition to penalties given by 53-3, a violation of this is a class C misdemeanor. The cop can't take your vehicle if you're being cited under this section unless it's authorized under 41-1a-1101, 41-6a-1405, 41-6a-1608, or 73-18-20.1 or required under 41-6a-527. Basically, don't drive at night without a 21-year-old next to you unless you're coming home from work.


41-8-3: Operation of vehicle by persons under 16 and six months -- Passenger limitations -- Exceptions -- Penalties.

(1) In addition to the provisions of Title 53, Chapter 3, Uniform Driver License Act, a person, whether resident or nonresident of this state, may not operate a motor vehicle upon any highway of this state with any passenger who is not an immediate family member of the driver until the earlier of:
(a) six months from the date the person's driver license was issued; or
(b) the person reaches 18 years of age.
(2) It is an affirmative defense to a charge under Subsection (1) that the person is operating a motor vehicle:
(a) accompanied by a licensed driver at least 21 years of age who is occupying a seat next to the driver;
(b) on assignment of a farmer or rancher and the driver is engaged in an agricultural operation; or
(c) in an emergency.
(3) In addition to any penalties imposed under Title 53, Chapter 3, Uniform Driver License Act, a violation of this section is a class C misdemeanor.
(4)
(a) Enforcement of this section by state or local law enforcement officers shall be only as a secondary action when an operator of a motor vehicle has been detained for a suspected violation of Title 41, other than this section, or for another offense.
(b) A peace officer may not seize or impound a vehicle if:
(i) the operator of the vehicle is cited for a violation of this section; and
(ii) the seizure or impoundment is not otherwise authorized under Section 41-1a-1101, 41-6a-1405, 41-6a-1608, or 73-18-20.1 or required under Section 41-6a-527.

In other words: You can't drive with a person who's not an immediate family member on any State highway until six months after you get your license or when you turn 18, whichever comes first unless there's a 21-year-old licensed driver in the passenger's seat, you're on an assignment from a farmer engaged in an agricultural operation, or you're in an emergency. Violation of this section is a class C misdemeanor. It's a secondary offense. The cop can't take your vehicle if you're cited under this section unless it's authorized or required by the same sections as noted in Section 2.


In addition to these contents, there has been no 'new' law; Sections 2 and 3, which are really the only ones in this Chapter ever discussed, have not been amended since 2006. I'm quite sure that that was the year that Section 3 and maybe Section 2 were created. In any case, my memory and judgment had erred when I cited Section 3 as justification for the day my friends and I piled into my friends' car and drove from the school to our AP Test, thinking that transportation to and from a school-sponsored activity was an exception to Section 3. However, the thing that surprised me the very most about my rereading of this Chapter is that Section 2 is not specifically mentioned as a secondary offense, but Section 3 is. I would hope that Section 2 would be a secondary offense by default, judging by the obvious illegality of a cop pulling someone over due solely to age appearance. In any case, I think that that's a loophole in the law about which I'll have to inquire a lawmaker. I hope this summary can help all others my age more fully understand the restrictions imposed upon them in the beginning of their holding a driver's license.

Comment below or e-mail me at jay@jayhutchinson.com. You can now also call me and leave a comment by voicemail at 801-513-1529. Follow me on Twitter at twitter.jayhutchinson.com.